EN
Country: EN (United States)
Select country/region

Language

  • English
stage-teaser-pace-durckluft-leckagen-2023-image-webx

Compressed air: room for improvement

When it comes to industrial applications, small leaks in compressed air systems are par for the course – and can mean substantial costs. SICK has now developed a solution for locating air pressure leaks, one that completed its pilot application at a major beverage bottler with flying colors.

They’re small, hard to find, and cost cold, hard cash: tiny leaks in the compressed air systems used in industrial production. Pressure losses of up to 30% are common. This not only harms performance, but, depending on the size of the plant, can cause annual costs in the five-digit euro range for a medium-sized enterprise – costs that could be avoided.

In March 2022, the Head of Production at one of nine German sites belonging to a major independent beverage bottler learned that SICK was working on a corresponding solution: in a publication from the Fraunhofer Institute for Manufacturing Engineering and Automation (IPA) on “Automated Leak Detection in Compressed Air Grids,” the solution, which the institute was jointly developing with SICK AG at the time, was presented. The two partners had decided to pool their resources for the project in the spring of 2021: SICK contributed its expertise in sensors, while the Fraunhofer IPA brought its AI and manufacturing engineering know-how to the table – the perfect combination.

For the Head of Production, one thing was clear: the application would be the ideal fit for his bottling site, which was home to various air-pressure-intensive processes – like inflating PET bottle preforms. Here, too, air pressure leaks were a well-known problem, one that his employees had already tried to track down by depicting consumption on a dashboard and by manually looking for leaks during downtimes on weekends – a situation that the Site Manager urgently wanted to change.

Data makes leaks visible
He got in touch with SICK, and it soon became clear: the two parties wanted to enter into a pilot project for this first practical application of the solution. This was followed by commissioning in the summer of 2022, and in mid-September 2022, the first filling line equipped with six FTMg (Flow Thermal Meter for Gases) sensors and the digital service commenced operations.

Here’s how it works: For specific lines, the sensors measure the pressure, temperature and flow volume of the compressed air, which allows them to calculate the energy contained within it. The data is saved on the device itself and on a web server and can be viewed by users at any time on a range of end devices – essentially, classic condition monitoring, which generates a wealth of information.

Evaluation with self-learning algorithm
But what sets the solution apart is the use of a gateway to connect the sensor data with the digital service Monitoring Box FTMg Premium: this specially designed cloud application uses a self-learning algorithm to analyze the sensor information, compare it with historical data, and convert the results into straightforward tables and diagrams. In this way, the system can independently identify line-specific deviations and/or spikes in consumption that point to potential leaks. In addition, the solution can provide profitability calculations, statistics and trends, as well as aggregated data that yields further insights, e.g. into the compressed air costs per unit produced or CO2 consumption per unit produced. The corresponding software for the data analysis was developed and tested by the data scientists at SICK in Hamburg.

By the end of September 2022, roughly ten days after the solution had been integrated into beverage bottling, the first data analysis was ready – and left the customer thoroughly impressed. This was followed by the installation of FTMgs on additional lines, and the second data analysis paved the way for implementing optimization measures in three filling machines. Over the next five months, 44 more FTMgs were installed on five of the site’s production lines.

Solution provides more transparency
The Site Manager’s assessment is thoroughly positive: “The solution offers us more transparency on our compressed air consumption per production line and machine, which allows us to compare different types of machines, precisely identify leaks and implement optimizations,” says the Head of Production. “This reduces downtimes and the time and expense for repairs, which boosts our production efficiency. Plus: it saves us quite a bit of money.”

The potential cost savings can be easily calculated: “The potential savings per year are roughly 1 million m³ of compressed air, which amounts to 57,000 euros on three machines,” says Eugene Lawrence, Strategic Solutions Manager, SICK, who was a central figure in the solution’s development. “And a second automatic analysis recently identified additional potential of 0.5 million m³ – from downtimes alone. That means the total potential is even higher, and we might be looking at nearly 100,000 euros in cost savings per year.”

Overall, the pilot project was a complete success, as Alexandra Schindler, Digital Business Consultant Integrated Automation at SICK, agrees: “That’s first and foremost due to the tremendous commitment on the part of the customer – it was an absolute windfall. We worked together on a very close and trusting basis,” she says. The solution was jointly adapted to the requirements for this first practical application and even expanded with an additional function: “In response to feedback from the customer, we added a new algorithm to the Monitoring Box FTMg Premium service, one that automatically records compressed air consumption when the lines are on standby – a component that had never existed before.” How satisfied the customer is can be seen from the fact that they also present the solution as the “best case” in their in-house com[1]munications. The solution is now slated for installation at two more of the bottler’s sites.

The potential savings per year are roughly 1 million m³ of compressed air, which amounts to 57,000 euros on three machines.

Eugene Lawrence, Strategic Solutions Manager, SICK

Cost savings + environmental protection
Following the successful pilot project, since October 2023 the solution has been available as a “regular” product worldwide – and is continually being refined. “For instance, right now we’re working to develop dynamic leak detection and a dynamic early-warning system, which will tentatively be available by mid-2024,” says Eugene Lawrence.

By the way
Beyond cost savings, environmental protection is a hefty argument in favor of the solution. “Companies are under increasing pressure to save energy and improve their carbon footprint. In this regard, too, identifying and repairing compressed air leaks holds tremendous potential,” says Alexandra Schindler.

Even if the specific solution for the beverage manufacturer is 100 percent an in-house SICK development it’s also important for collaboration between SICK and the Fraunhofer IPA: for example, its practical application provided valuable insights and helped identify further challenges that the two partners are now jointly addressing. In addition, they are working together to steadily refine the algorithms and learn even more from the data – which, in turn, will inform and improve SICK’s future customer solutions.